Communication, Media, and Development Policy

Analysis, Ideas and Debates on Development Policy Issues from Communication and Media Perspectives

Comments and Questions Related to Media Development or Media for Development?: wrong question - but what’s the right one?


media in development


whatever social/national good development organisations pursue to achieve, media can play a prominent role in that achievement. however, capacities and performances are varied across the mainstream media. for influential and bigger media the roles sometimes can be distinctly very prescriptive, regardless of its being of universal good or not, if any such. debates over roles and responsibilities of both media and development organisations rather fuel unnecessary tensions between these two development actors, given their roles are understood to that context. hence rather a set of norms and standards for the both supporting the 'development'- being common for the both based on certain common understanding under a certain context despite having a very varied concept to agree to, need developing and practising for any work in development.


Media for development


Annonymous, the problem is that there is no agreement about how you get "free of the shackles of poverty and economic oppression", and that is why media for development is so different to media development. Media for development involves an outsider's view of what development means and has a message which is usually driven by the donor's view. Developing media should mean encouraging good journalism which stimulates debate and dialogue in civil society about what is the best development path for the country. Whilst there are shared objectives between the two, media for development is very different and should be clearly differentiated. Media development should be a much more 'hands-off' intervention (if that is not an oxymoron!), with less of an agenda on the table.

Development organisations should ask themselves why they are involved in encouraging a freer and more plural media? With so many media organisations (e.g. Free Media Movement) supporting media development with no overt connection to 'development' in the sense we are discussing here, and with no 'vision' of what development means, what do development organisations bring to the table? Perhaps there is always an agenda from the development community, whether they like to admit it or not! Perhaps 'development' should stay out of media development and stick to media for development?


Media Responsibility


I don't think the media has kept things in focus while acquiring huge influence in the world. Treating the news as 'entertainment' and putting forth whatever editors deem worthy of the public's attention is rarely what we should hear or see. And too often the media falls in with politic individuals when it should not be endorsing anyone. But, it seems to be self governing and no one is holding it accountable. Like the business world, the media needs to be regulated.

Regards
Janet


Media and Development


For the poor developing countries the debate about media development and media for development sounds pedantic and obscurantist.The reality is whether the media be instrumentalist or intrinsic matters least so long they are able to communicate the message about the ways of getting free of the shackles of poverty and economic oppression.






Be the first to comment!


Post Your Comment or Question:
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

The CI with

Comments on Blogs



Add our RSS feed

Recent Posts


Add our RSS feed

Social Climate Change 
Nobel Intentions 
Northern Lights 
Government Rules! 
Show me the Media Money - but what should we do with it? 
Little Green People 
Whose Policy is it Anyway? 
Can we put a value on the good that media do? A social cost approach to media development 
Percussive Effects 
A gutsy new DFID White Paper puts the politics back into development 
The commonalities lens sees AIDS better 
Battle Star Development: Prescriptions vs. Platforms 
Trading Rights 
Another Development 
Scaling Steep Slopes - The Public Policies Helping to Transform Medellin 
Accountability, media and the development system: a complicated romance 
People, Ideas and Things 
Donors, Governance and Media Aid: Some Thoughts from Sierra Leone  
ChangeNet: The Lessons from Obama's campaign for International Development Democracy and Governance Policy and Action 
Cable News 
Democratic Adjustment? 
Should international development NGOs play a major role in media for development? 
A Robust Research Agenda on Media and Democracy in Fragile States: Getting a More Serious Conversation Going 
Governance and the Media: the engagement gap 
A "democratic recession" presents challenges - and opportunities 
The TransAtlantic Taskforce on Development: great report, but where is the development and democracy debate headed? 
Development Street - no Wall? 
Media and democracy in fragile states: the promises and problems of policy relevant research  
Deportation of Rex Gardner is a Weak Attempt to Intimidate Fiji Media 
The media debate in the UK is unique - but the challenge of subsidising independent public interest media has urgent implications for democracy everywhere 
The Athenian Way!...or should that be "Why?" 
Winds of Change - Media Development Trends and Questions 
The Fairness Doctrine: is this the first big media debate under Obama and what does it mean for media development? 
Disaster-affected communities are and should be the architects of their own recovery, not merely passive recipients of international goodwill 
OBAMA, DEVELOPMENT, AID, and GRANDMOTHERS! 
Is a free and plural media more important than elections in securing democratic development? 
Media Development or Media for Development?: wrong question - but what’s the right one?  
A Rose by Any Other Name is Still a...the basis for one coherent Communication and Media Development field of work  
Accra: The big tent approach to development ends in agreement – and information is one of the big winners 
Where the European Union meets the African Union on media development 
Community Radio Initiators Ready to Run the Stations Soon in Bangladesh 
Re-vamping UNICEF’s Africa Communication for Development Strategy 
Accra Aid Effectiveness conference: can there be real “country ownership” without public debate? 
Big Investors - The Vacant Low Level Seat at the Accra High Level Development Effectiveness Summit 
Kenya Political Violence - Were Media Responsible? 
Tides of Hope? 
Miming Development: The Shortest Distance and International Development 
Over the Edge! 
Power of Movement 
Science Envy?: A Communication Perspective on the Core Principles that Guide International Development Interventions 
Talk with the People! 
AIDS Lines 
I Blame Smallpox 
I Had [I Think] A Dream 
Little Big Communication 

Your Recent Posts