Communication, Media, and Development Policy

Analysis, Ideas and Debates on Development Policy Issues from Communication and Media Perspectives

Left in the Dark: The Unmet Need for Information in Humanitarian Responses


Policy Briefing #2

Author

Imogen Wall
Lisa Robinson

BBC World Trust Service

Publication Date

October 28, 2008

Summary

This 8-page policy briefing is about the value of information and communication to disaster-affected populations. It provides background, examples, and recommendations for agencies to "mainstream" this kind of communication as a priority emergency response in serving disaster victims. Its three parts explore: 1) evidence that information is regarded by affected populations as a critical issue, and what they identify as information needs; 2) the current situation, in which few information and communication demands are being met; why this is; and what structures, systems, and skills are missing; and 3) some clear steps that can be taken to resolve these issues.

The demand for information is presented through the example of the response of Tsunami victims in Aceh. The greatest dissatisfaction of the victims, as stated here, was over the poor information flow. According to the document: "Disaster victims need information about their options in order to take any meaningful choices about their future. Like anyone else, they make decisions based on the best possible information available to them at the time." As the physical and psychological needs of disaster survivors change over time, information needs change also. The stages of information in the aftermath of a disaster begin with the need to know what happened, how to get immediate survival needs satisfied, and what has happened to family members and friends. Providing answers decreases panic and increases survivor capacity to take action. Due to loss of normal information channels, including personnel and infrastructure for radio, television, and telephones, information can become least accessible to those who most need it.


Information needs increase as survivors look for availability of fresh water, shelter, and medical attention. Expectation management is a component of communication at this stage, as relief may not fulfill needs as quickly as expected. In a subsequent stage, people want to know what relief services are available and to what they are entitled. They need to know about recently implemented policies that affect them, such as housing reconstruction guidelines or victim compensation policies. Accountability, responsibility, and transparency of the government and relief agencies need to be communicated. Safety instructions and support of emergency workers are also communication needs.


Unmet communication needs can lead to further trauma and stress. "In particular, psychosocial studies increasingly note that information deprivation actually causes stress and exacerbates trauma..." for those who are internally displaced and have been unable to locate family or friends. Information is needed to give people "a sense of power and purpose over their own destiny. People who have knowledge of issues such as when and where food will be distributed, the amount of allocated rations per person, and how to cook the rations to maximise nutritional value, can help manage logistics, reduce corruption, and improve health and mental wellbeing." The provision of information thus becomes a form of aid and is, as stated here, deserving of prioritisation through the development of effective and properly resourced communication strategies.

However, information and communication needs have been unmet in previous emergencies. In detailing the reasons for unmet humanitarian communication needs, the document points to confusion about the organisational location of this aid, considering that it requires expertise and infrastructural preparation different from public relations. "The humanitarian system as it stands is not equipped with either the capacity or the resources to begin tackling the challenge of providing information to those affected by crises. There is very little dedicated public communications capacity within major humanitarian organisations."


The recommendations to remedy the organisational gaps include:

  • In emergency agencies, make someone responsible and accountable for information and communication needs of people in disaster situations. Choose someone with expertise in participatory media programming for affected populations, who understands the information needs of beneficiaries in emergencies, can devise strategic responses to meeting them, and provide the focal point for implementing them.
  • In order to present consistent information, plan for coordination and strategic links to allied information efforts, including advocating for strong government communication planning.
  • Make regional disaster risk reduction plans, including media landscape studies which map out a population’s regular media access (including mobile phones, internet, film shows, videos, camp radios, etc.) and usage under normal circumstances.
  • Invest in preparing for emergency information needs, particularly preparing supplies to deploy within 48 hours of a disaster. Include stockpiling equipment - key broadcasting equipment for damaged stations, wind-up radios, 'radio in a box', or ‘radio station in a suitcase’ - and preparing emergency lifesaving information packages in appropriate forms.
  • Develop a prior understanding of how populations in disaster-prone areas source information to determine the best channels for information flow: for example, local media, local religious networks, and local civil society groups.
  • Ensure early and frequent two-way communication with affected populations, understanding not only what populations need, but also what they need and want to know.
  • Understand and facilitate the ability of local populations to source, share, and transmit information through new technologies.
  • Build, as well as restore, communication infrastructures.
  • Turn more donor attention to the role of communications strategies within projects that they are funding – commission studies on information needs related to disaster relief, build budget lines for funding communication in affected communities, ensure local government funding and expertise for their citizen outreach, consider funding newsletters and other channels dedicated to information response.

  • Contact

    BBC World Service Trust

    Room 301 NE
    PO Box 76
    Bush House
    Strand

    London
    WC2B 4PH
    United Kingdom (UK)
    Tel: +44 (0)207 557 2462
    Fax: +44 (0)207 379 1622

    Source

    BBC World Trust Service website accessed on November 4 2008.


    Placed on the Communication Initiative site November 04 2008
    Last Updated November 06 2008



    How useful did you find the knowledge and contacts on this page to your work?


    4
    Average: 4 (1 vote)
    Your rating: None

    Be the first to comment!


    Post Your Comment or Question:
    CAPTCHA
    This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

    The CI with

    Comments on Blogs



    Add our RSS feed

    Recent Posts


    Add our RSS feed

    Social Climate Change 
    Nobel Intentions 
    Northern Lights 
    Government Rules! 
    Show me the Media Money - but what should we do with it? 
    Little Green People 
    Whose Policy is it Anyway? 
    Can we put a value on the good that media do? A social cost approach to media development 
    Percussive Effects 
    A gutsy new DFID White Paper puts the politics back into development 
    The commonalities lens sees AIDS better 
    Battle Star Development: Prescriptions vs. Platforms 
    Trading Rights 
    Another Development 
    Scaling Steep Slopes - The Public Policies Helping to Transform Medellin 
    Accountability, media and the development system: a complicated romance 
    People, Ideas and Things 
    Donors, Governance and Media Aid: Some Thoughts from Sierra Leone  
    ChangeNet: The Lessons from Obama's campaign for International Development Democracy and Governance Policy and Action 
    Cable News 
    Democratic Adjustment? 
    Should international development NGOs play a major role in media for development? 
    A Robust Research Agenda on Media and Democracy in Fragile States: Getting a More Serious Conversation Going 
    Governance and the Media: the engagement gap 
    A "democratic recession" presents challenges - and opportunities 
    The TransAtlantic Taskforce on Development: great report, but where is the development and democracy debate headed? 
    Development Street - no Wall? 
    Media and democracy in fragile states: the promises and problems of policy relevant research  
    Deportation of Rex Gardner is a Weak Attempt to Intimidate Fiji Media 
    The media debate in the UK is unique - but the challenge of subsidising independent public interest media has urgent implications for democracy everywhere 
    The Athenian Way!...or should that be "Why?" 
    Winds of Change - Media Development Trends and Questions 
    The Fairness Doctrine: is this the first big media debate under Obama and what does it mean for media development? 
    Disaster-affected communities are and should be the architects of their own recovery, not merely passive recipients of international goodwill 
    OBAMA, DEVELOPMENT, AID, and GRANDMOTHERS! 
    Is a free and plural media more important than elections in securing democratic development? 
    Media Development or Media for Development?: wrong question - but what’s the right one?  
    A Rose by Any Other Name is Still a...the basis for one coherent Communication and Media Development field of work  
    Accra: The big tent approach to development ends in agreement – and information is one of the big winners 
    Where the European Union meets the African Union on media development 
    Community Radio Initiators Ready to Run the Stations Soon in Bangladesh 
    Re-vamping UNICEF’s Africa Communication for Development Strategy 
    Accra Aid Effectiveness conference: can there be real “country ownership” without public debate? 
    Big Investors - The Vacant Low Level Seat at the Accra High Level Development Effectiveness Summit 
    Kenya Political Violence - Were Media Responsible? 
    Tides of Hope? 
    Miming Development: The Shortest Distance and International Development 
    Over the Edge! 
    Power of Movement 
    Science Envy?: A Communication Perspective on the Core Principles that Guide International Development Interventions 
    Talk with the People! 
    AIDS Lines 
    I Blame Smallpox 
    I Had [I Think] A Dream 
    Little Big Communication 

    Your Recent Posts